As the MLB regular season winds down in late September 2025, MLB The Show 25 captures the same intensity seen in real ballparks across the country. Lineups tighten, pitchers get sharper, and the infield becomes the heartbeat of every championship squad. Whether it's a slick backhand at short, a laser across the MLB The Show 25 Stubs diamond from third, or a scoop at first that saves an inning, great infielders separate contenders from pretenders.

Recent patches have tweaked player attributes, adjusting contact, reaction time, and fielding animations in subtle but significant ways. Meta shifts have reshaped which infielders stand out in Diamond Dynasty, and new cards-driven by September call-ups and postseason heroes-are now influencing how players build their teams. Below is a breakdown of the top-tier infielders for MLB The Show 25, divided by position, performance, and playstyle versatility.

S-Tier: The Elite Core

These are the infielders every player dreams of anchoring their lineup with-defensive wizards who also bring elite contact, clutch power, and plate discipline. They define the current MLB The Show 25 meta and perform in every mode, from Ranked Seasons to Battle Royale.

1. Mookie Betts (2B/SS)
Betts continues to dominate the infield meta. His 99-rated Diamond card combines near-perfect fielding, exceptional contact versus both sides, and elite reaction stats. What truly sets him apart is his flexibility-he's just as reliable at second base as he is at shortstop, letting you adapt your lineup to fit chemistry and boosts. His swing remains one of the smoothest in the game, with pinpoint PCI coverage that rewards timing.

2. Rafael Devers (3B)
Devers brings thunder to the hot corner. His "September Surge" program card boasts maxed-out power against right-handers and a swing that punishes mistakes. Defensively, he's improved from early patches, with faster reaction animations and reduced error rates on hard-hit balls. Players who thrive on aggressive hitting will find Devers nearly unstoppable in clutch moments.

3. Matt Olson (1B)
The gold standard at first base, Olson's 99 Power and 95 Fielding make him an easy lock for most endgame teams. His defense often gets overlooked, but his ability to stretch and dig out low throws saves runs every game. In the current meta-where errors are more punishing-Olson's sure hands make him more than just a slugger.

4. Trea Turner (SS/2B)
Turner's "Postseason Flashback" card has reemerged as a fan favorite thanks to his elite speed and balanced hitting attributes. His bunt and slap-hit mechanics make him an on-base machine, and his 99 Speed rating creates chaos on the basepaths. When paired with players like Betts or Devers, Turner turns singles into doubles and doubles into runs.

A-Tier: Reliable and Versatile

These infielders may not have the absolute elite stats, but they remain must-have options for those seeking dependable production on both sides of the ball. They shine in specific situations and can outperform higher-rated cards when used strategically.

1. José Ramírez (3B/2B)
Ramírez's switch-hitting versatility is invaluable. His "Finest" card gives him solid power splits and excellent vision, allowing him to adjust easily to different pitching styles. Defensively, he's agile, though his arm strength limits him slightly at third compared to others. Still, for players who prioritize offense and utility, Ramírez offers top-tier flexibility.

2. Freddie Freeman (1B)
Freeman may not have Olson's raw power, but his consistent contact and fielding grace make him one of the smoothest left-handed swings in MLB The Show 25. His clutch rating remains among the best, making him deadly in late innings. He's the definition of reliability-never the flashiest, but rarely a liability.

3. Marcus Semien (2B/SS)
Semien's "All-Star Rewind" version combines respectable power with gold-tier fielding. He thrives in offline modes and can anchor mid-tier ranked teams, offering a blend of contact and plate discipline that complements aggressive lineups. His bat speed feels faster than the numbers suggest, making him a sneaky pick for players who rely on timing windows.

4. Bo Bichette (SS)
Bichette's improved swing path and contact stats after the latest update make him one of the more underrated shortstops. His glove has always been reliable, but the extra pop in his bat now lets him drive pitches into the gap with authority. For players avoiding the stub-heavy chase for Turner or Betts, Bichette is an excellent substitute.

B-Tier: Solid Options and Budget Beasts

Not everyone has the luxury of stacking their roster with Diamonds, and these B-Tier players provide excellent value. They might not dominate every game, but they'll hold their own in most matchups.

1. Nolan Arenado (3B)
Still a defensive master, Arenado's reflexes and arm make him a vacuum at third. However, his bat has slightly lagged behind recent meta shifts. His power versus right-handers has dipped, but in offline or Conquest modes, he remains a consistent RBI threat.

2. Jake Cronenworth (2B)
Cronenworth's "Future Franchise" card is a budget gem. Great contact, solid fielding, and surprising speed make him a balanced infielder for new or free-to-play players. He fits perfectly in early Diamond Dynasty builds when you're still working through programs.

3. Paul Goldschmidt (1B)
Goldy's hitting ratings have taken a step back in the latest patch, but he remains a capable all-around player with excellent discipline. His swing timing window feels forgiving, making him a good fit for players who struggle with high-velocity pitching.

4. Dansby Swanson (SS)
A fielding-first option, Swanson's glove and range make him perfect for defensive lineups. His hitting isn't elite, but he can turn a crucial double play or rob a liner that would ruin a pitcher's outing. In Ranked play, he's a situational weapon when defense matters most.

Meta Trends and Closing Thoughts

As MLB The Show 25 evolves through late-season patches, infield balance continues to shift toward versatile, multi-positional players. Fielding ratings and reaction times have taken on greater weight, reducing the dominance of pure power bats that once ruled Diamond Dynasty. Players who combine speed, defense, and bat control-like Betts, Turner, and Devers-define the modern infield meta.

For those building their ultimate lineup, the best approach is balance. Anchor your corners with power bats like Olson or Devers, lock down the middle with speedsters like Turner or Semien, and fill the gaps with clutch contact hitters like Freeman or Ramírez.

And if stubs are running low, don't let the grind slow you down-services like MMOEXP offer fast, secure deliveries to help you stock your team and stay competitive without endless hours of farming.

In MLB The Show 25, infielders are more than just defenders-they're game-changers. With the right combination of gloves and bats, you'll not only protect your lead but also build the MLB The Show Stubs for sale foundation of a World Series-caliber roster.