As MLB The Show 25 continues to evolve with each update, player performance and card availability constantly shift the landscape of Diamond Dynasty. September, in particular, has brought a slew of standout infielders whose impact on both offense and defense cannot be overstated. In this guide, we break down the top infielders of the month, placing them into a tiered structure based on their stats, versatility, and MLB The Show 25 Stubs overall utility for team-building in MLB The Show 25.

S-Tier Infielders: Elite Impact

S-Tier infielders represent the cream of the crop. These players not only deliver exceptional offensive production but also provide defensive reliability, making them indispensable for any lineup.

Fernando Tatis Jr. (SS) – Padres

Tatis Jr. remains a must-have for any competitive squad. With elite contact and power ratings, combined with speed that can turn routine singles into doubles, he is the ultimate leadoff hitter or cleanup option. His defensive metrics at shortstop are top-tier, allowing players to trust him on double-play situations. For September, his card has been slightly upgraded, reflecting his real-life hot streak, making him even more formidable.

José Ramírez (3B) – Guardians

Ramírez combines power, contact, and agility in a package that few can match. His offensive stats make him a consistent home run threat, while his fielding at third base is steady enough to handle tough grounders. In Diamond Dynasty, Ramírez's hybrid skill set makes him ideal for both lineup flexibility and high-stakes games.

Freddie Freeman (1B) – Dodgers

Freeman has always been a consistent force at first base, and his September card continues that trend. He excels at hitting for power without sacrificing contact. With solid fielding stats, Freeman is not just a batsman but a reliable defensive anchor. He’s particularly effective in clutch situations, making him a cornerstone for late-inning strategies.

A-Tier Infielders: High Value Players

A-Tier infielders are excellent performers who can influence games significantly but might lack the elite stats or versatility of S-Tier players.

Marcus Semien (2B/SS) – Blue Jays

Semien’s versatility allows him to play both second base and shortstop without a noticeable drop in performance. His offensive numbers are strong, with a blend of home run power and gap-hitting ability. Defensively, he is agile and reliable, making him an A-Tier asset for teams seeking depth in the middle infield.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (1B) – Blue Jays

Guerrero Jr. remains a towering presence at first base, capable of clearing the fences with ease. While his defensive stats are slightly lower compared to elite-tier first basemen, his bat compensates, providing consistent offensive firepower. His September card reflects a slight uptick in contact ratings, making him a dangerous presence in any lineup.

Ozzie Albies (2B) – Braves

Albies brings speed and contact ability to the second base position. He is particularly effective as a leadoff hitter or a base-stealing threat. While not as dominant in power as some of his peers, his defensive reliability and offensive versatility make him a high-value addition to A-Tier rosters.

B-Tier Infielders: Reliable Contributors

B-Tier infielders provide solid contributions but may have limitations in either defense, power, or consistency. They are best used as complementary pieces or situational starters.

Nolan Arenado (3B) – Cardinals

Arenado’s fielding is elite, often making plays that others simply cannot. His offensive output is consistent but lacks the game-breaking power seen in top-tier peers. He is best suited for players who value defense highly or want a steady bat in the middle of the lineup.

Matt Chapman (3B) – Rays

Chapman excels at defense, particularly in handling tough bunts and choppers. His bat is reliable but slightly below A-Tier standards. For players looking to shore up the hot corner defensively, Chapman is a dependable choice, especially in high-pressure games.

Gleyber Torres (2B/SS) – Yankees

Torres provides a balance of offensive and defensive skills but lacks the consistency to push him into A-Tier. His speed is useful for baserunning and defensive coverage, making him a versatile but situational option.

C-Tier Infielders: Situational Options

C-Tier infielders can fill roles in your lineup but are often situational picks rather than cornerstone pieces. They may lack the stats to be competitive against top-tier opponents in ranked games but are valuable for casual or co-op matches.

Brandon Lowe (2B) – Rays

Lowe’s offensive upside is evident in certain matchups, particularly against left-handed pitchers. However, his defensive limitations and inconsistent production place him in the C-Tier for September. He is a useful platoon option but not a day-one starter for high-stakes games.

Javier Báez (SS/2B) – Tigers

Báez is an electrifying player with excellent speed and flashy defense. Despite his skill, his inconsistency at the plate and susceptibility to strikeouts limits his utility in ranked play. For casual lineups, he can be a game-changer, particularly in small-ball strategies.

Considerations for Team-Building in September

When crafting your Diamond Dynasty lineup this month, consider the following:

Position Flexibility: Players like Semien and Torres who can cover multiple infield positions provide tactical flexibility and insurance against injuries.

Baserunning Impact: Speedsters like Tatis Jr. and Albies can shift momentum with stolen bases, forcing pitchers to alter their approach.

Defensive Anchors: Elite fielders like Arenado and Chapman can prevent runs in ways that purely offensive players cannot, a factor often overlooked in team-building.

Hot Streak Adjustments: September cards often reflect real-life hot streaks. Keeping an eye on monthly upgrades ensures your lineup stays competitive.

Conclusion

September’s MLB The Show 25 infielders bring a mix of power, speed, and defensive prowess that can transform a lineup. S-Tier options like Tatis Jr., Ramírez, and Freeman are essential for high-level play, while A-Tier and B-Tier infielders offer depth and strategic flexibility. C-Tier players can fill niche roles, particularly in co-op or casual settings. By understanding the tiered hierarchy of infielders this month, players can optimize their Diamond Dynasty rosters cheap MLB The Show Stubs and dominate the field through both offense and defense.

Whether you’re chasing home runs, building a shutdown defense, or focusing on speed and versatility, this September tier list provides the insights necessary to elevate your team to the next level in MLB The Show 25.